"My instinct is there’s no silver bullet for overcoming the barriers holding this market back."
- John Godfrey - Equity Release Council
A new white paper by Air, The Home Belongs in the Plan: Voices from the Industry, sees senior industry figures calling on the FCA to make it mandatory for lenders and brokers to tell older borrowers about all their later life options, including equity release.
The white paper looks at why so few mortgage brokers write or refer equity release and draws on interviews with contributors such as AMI, more2life, SimplyBiz, the London Institute of Banking & Finance, Legal & General, StepChange, Cornerstone, Key Group and the Equity Release Council.
This comes as the FCA carries out a market study into later life mortgages, examining how housing wealth could play a bigger role in retirement provision. Interim findings are due by the end of the year.
In June, the regulator’s director of retail banking, Emad Aladhal, spoke of his desire to see later life lending become a fourth pillar of retirement funding alongside the state pension, workplace pensions and personal pensions.
However, the latest annual figures from the Equity Release Council showed that Equity release lending was £2.57bn last year, less than a twentieth of the £60bn Air estimates is lent to borrowers aged 55 and over each year, including product transfers.
Will Hale, chief executive of Air, said "significant intervention" was needed to make sure older borrowers hear about all their options and can reach the right advice.
"The FCA should require all lenders and advisers to make customers aware of all relevant options and provide effective routes to appropriate advice," he said. "Practical guidance should cover product transfers, the boundaries between advice and execution only services and the responsibilities of firms making and receiving referrals."
Charlotte Allen, chief compliance and risk officer at Key Group, said leaving the sector to act alone would "not move the dial."
"We need finalised guidance, backed up with practical examples on when a lifetime mortgage may be appropriate,” she added. “Firms should also be required to clearly define the target market for their advice model and proposition, so they understand which parts of their customer base may be suitable.
"Even straightforward mortgage product transfers shouldn’t proceed without customers being made aware of other options that may be suitable for them. That’s another expectation I’d like to see included in the FCA’s guidance."
Other contributors to Air’s white paper stopped short of urging the FCA to make it mandatory for lenders and brokers to flag all options but called for greater guidance.
John Godfrey, chair of the Equity Release Council, said: "Those under-saved in a pension sense may need to understand their property position in order to set themselves up for retirement, which would need advisers to take a more rounded view - but wouldn’t necessarily require mandatory commitments enforced by the FCA.
"My instinct is there’s no silver bullet for overcoming the barriers holding this market back. We need an approach to regulation that focuses on outcomes and allows the industry to develop its own standards within a clear, principles-based framework.
"The regulator can be very helpful by laying out more clearly just what excellence does look like in practice, with some good examples, and state some principles that generally relate to predictability and stability rather than retrospective regulation over previous standards."
Andrew Needham, head of network relationships at Cornerstone Finance Group, added: "I’d like to see clearer guidance around when advisers should be considering later life options. Not every adviser needs to become a later life specialist, but everyone should be able to spot when a client might need that conversation and know where to send them."
Separately, Stephanie Charman, chief executive of the Association of Mortgage Intermediaries (AMI), said FCA guidance would help steer consumer awareness but urged the sector not to wait for the regulator to take the lead with new rules.
Charman said: "There also needs to be demonstrable progress from the sector itself by coming together to overcome barriers, rather than simply waiting for the FCA to take the lead with new handbook guidelines.
"Consumer awareness needs continued communication around the need for solutions, as people get closer to retirement, so guidance from the FCA will be useful here to steer this. Access to solutions is important too, and advice is key here to overcome scepticism and make sure they have guidance for the right solution for them and their needs.
"People need their mortgages to adapt to their life cycles, and advice should be central to talking through what is right: whether that’s overpayments, interest only, term changes, and understanding what they’re not getting by not having advice."
With the FCA set to publish its interim view in Q4, Dave Harris, chief executive of more2life, urged the regulator to be bold in its actions: "My hope is that the regulator says either what they expect to happen now or that they change the rules.
"This can be tackled by making sure all mortgage types are described to customers at the outset; then if you don’t have the qualifications as an adviser, you have to ensure you can point to an effective referral."


