Average new build property prices are below the government's Your First Home price threshold in just 88 of England's 295 local authority districts, meaning that only 30% of districts offer an average new build price within the scheme's eligibility limit.
The latest research from UK Property Development (UKPD) compared the latest average new build property prices across 295 local authority districts in England against the respective local price thresholds proposed under the Your First Home scheme.
The findings suggest that the scheme could have a relatively limited reach in practice, with average new build prices exceeding the local threshold in the remaining 207 districts, accounting for 70% of the locations analysed.
Stevenage emerges as the location where average new build prices sit furthest below the local Your First Home threshold. With a price cap of £450,000 and an average new-build price of £217,632, the average property is 51.6% below the permitted limit.
Redbridge ranks second, where the £500,000 threshold is 40.5% above the average new build price of £297,264. Newham follows in third place, with average prices of £402,014 sitting 38.2% below its £650,000 threshold.
Barking and Dagenham also offers a sizeable gap between the two figures (-38%) while Birmingham, completes the top five with an average new build price 37.9% below the local Your First Home threshold.
At the other end of the table, St Albans records the largest disparity between average new build prices and the local Your First Home threshold. The average new build property price in the area stands at just over £1m, more than double the local price cap of £515,000, representing an affordability gap of 109.2%.
Oxford follows, where average prices of £797,911 are 92.3% above the £415,000 threshold. In the City of London, the average new build price of £1,177,477 is 81.2% higher than the £650,000 cap.
Derbyshire Dales and Chesterfield also feature among the five areas with the largest price disparities, with gaps of 74.4% and 73.5% respectively.
Director of UK Property Development, Andy Morrison, commented: "The Your First Home scheme has the potential to offer valuable support to first-time buyers, but the real test will be whether there are enough suitable new build properties available within the local price thresholds.
"Our research highlights a significant geographical divide. In some areas, the average new build property price sits comfortably below the permitted threshold, giving buyers a much more realistic prospect of finding an eligible home. In others, the average price is considerably higher, which could make it much harder for first-time buyers to take advantage of the scheme.
"It will be particularly interesting to see whether housebuilders respond by bringing smaller, more affordable new-build properties to market, helping to ensure that the scheme translates into genuine homeownership opportunities rather than simply another policy that looks good on paper.
"Ultimately, the success of Your First Home will depend not just on the financial support available, but on whether developers can deliver the right type of housing, at the right price, in the areas where first-time buyers need it most."


