Two thirds of consumers say mortgage information provided by AI was either generic or incorrect/unsuitable for their circumstances, highlighting how brokers can make personalisation their point of difference as AI becomes part of the mortgage journey.
Artificial intelligence may be changing the way people research their mortgage, but the research from Coventry for intermediaries suggests there’s still a sizeable gap between getting an answer and getting one that reflects a customer’s individual circumstances.
When using AI to research mortgage options, only 33% of respondents said the information they received was accurate, while 67% said it was either not relevant to their circumstances or was incorrect.
Accuracy emerged as a consistent concern throughout the research. More than a quarter (28%) said receiving inaccurate information was their biggest concern when using AI for their mortgage, while 12% were most worried that nobody would be accountable if the information was incorrect. One in ten (10%) pointed to AI not being regulated by the FCA as their biggest concern.
Speed and convenience appear to be a major part of AI's appeal. Almost a third (31%) said their biggest motivation was that AI is quick and easy to ask, while 14% said they already use AI for most of their day-to-day information and research.
The research also found AI is beginning to shape mortgage conversations before customers reach a broker, with almost a third (32%) of people using it before seeking professional advice. That means some customers may arrive at their first broker conversation having already researched the buying process, mortgage terminology, potential repayments or how much they could borrow.
Jonathan Stinton, head of intermediaries at Coventry Building Society, commented: “AI can give you an answer in seconds - the harder part is knowing if that answer is right for you. Customers need to understand the difference between information, structured guidance and regulated advice, and what each can and can’t do.
“The best mortgage recommendations aren’t generic, they’re personal. When a broker is sitting in front of you, they’ll know the important questions to ask, whether they need to dig deeper, and which details could change the options available. That judgment is hard to replace.
“As customers get better at finding information for themselves, the broker's value isn't simply knowing things the customer doesn't. It's understanding the whole picture, applying that expertise to someone’s circumstances and recommending what’s right for them.
“Knowing the facts is one thing, applying them correctly to someone’s real life is another. Brokers need to get comfortable with the fact that customers may increasingly arrive having already asked AI. Rather than seeing that as competition, ask what they’ve found, sense-check it, and use it as a starting point for a more personal conversation.”


